How to make it believable

eye-716008_1280

Recently, I had a discussion with a friend that went something like this, “Well, then why didn’t she say anything sooner?”  I’m sure you have all seen or heard something similar, right?  But when we try to explain the fear that comes with speaking out, it’s dismissed as being stupid.  Doesn’t matter if that’s speaking up about sexual harassment, rape, or just bad service.  The reality is that most women get this, and a very small segment of men do not.

It’s called privilege.  One of my friends is a comfortably middle class, white, Christian, conservative male.  He ticks off every single checkbox.  Now, he’s a great guy, and possibly one of the most giving people I know, but he can’t even begin to understand what it would be like to suffer at the mercy of society.  To him, if there’s a problem, just speak up.

He can’t envision the fear of all the possible repercussions.  No one has that much power over his life.  If his boss does him wrong, he’ll just get a new job.  There’s plenty of places he could work.  The idea of having a black mark for being one of “those” types of people on his resume is unimaginable.  As a pretty good sized fella, trying to understand the fear of being overpowered is even harder.

And yet, in my writing, sexism is a topic I address pretty often.  Mostly because while we live in a world that is more equal than ever before, it’s still not EQUAL.  My friend knows that no woman would ever come up and grab his dick and shove her tongue down his throat.  In his mind, if something like that happened, she’d look like a supermodel so he wouldn’t mind.  When I asked him how he’d feel about an obese old lady doing it, he basically said, “Well, I wouldn’t let her get that close.”

Because he COULD physically stop her.

He can’t understand.  He’s never had to be afraid of the dark corners on the street.  He’s never wondered if the person he’s meeting for that online date is going to abuse him.  He’s never had to question whether his supervisor’s smile is leading up to a very complicated situation.  He’s never been in a situation where didn’t have the power to change things.

In my stories, I like to flip things around.  Make the damsel in distress become the hero, turn the villain into the savior, and things like that.  In this case, I’m completely stumped.  I have no idea how to take the powerful (especially when it comes to sexual harassment) and make them the powerless – at least not with any plausibility.  Sure, I can chain a guy down (in a book, people!) and have some horrible person do horrible things, but those aren’t the types of stories I write.

This time, though, I’m stumped.  I have no idea how to remove the privilege, and without it, my characters just aren’t believable.  The saddest part is that I think that says more about society than my skill as an author.

 

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “How to make it believable

  1. I just shared this with some friends of mine (male and female) and it started a huge discussion. Long story short….we can’t find a solution either. Other then that people feel privileged because they BELIEVE in something. Change their beliefs and you MIGHT change the feeling of being privileged. But changing someone’s belief is almost impossible.
    I believe that people can change but they need the right motivation, motivation that is incredibly personal to them or it becomes a passing phase.
    One friend said why not just kill the sods off (he meant in your books). Of course being male that seems like the logical option. But actions aren’t always the answer. What boring literature we would be reading if that was the case.

    Prime example. Last night I was with my hubby and he was flicking through the sky cinema channels (I’m knitting next to him making my baby girl a hat) and he puts on 50 shades darker just at the point where Ana is being intimidated by her boss and he corners her against the door. Now my hubby turned to me and asked “he doesn’t hit her does he?” And I said “watch it and you will find out!” My hubby shook his head and flicked to a different channel, he didn’t want to watch another man use his privilege and belief that he can do what he wants. It wasn’t until ten minutes had passed that he said “she doesn’t sleep with him does she?” Genuinely worried what a woman might have felt like she HAD to do something to please her boss.

    Auryn I hope you find a solution, when you do please tell us about it and share it with the world.

    Like

    1. I’m trying. The small-minded part of me thinks that people won’t understand until they’ve been in that situation, but I should know better. I have my own privilege. I’m seen as a white, heterosexual, middle-class woman. I get certain benefits from that which others can’t imagine, and yet I can empathize – so clearly the entire world doesn’t have to suffer to make the point.

      So, I’ll just keep trying to make my friend understand until I figure out a method that works. Oh, and expect to see this subject in some future works of mine. 😉

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s